Results 1 to 7 of 7

Thread: Ight, Imma Head Out

  1. #1

    Default Ight, Imma Head Out

    Hi, I have not really played for long here, but I don’t really feel comfortable playing anymore. Regarding that one issue regarding the hatchling dragon drinking thing, I appreciate the community’s attempts to try and sway me over into accepting it, but the method of doing so was lacking. Admittedly my own reservations were lacking in body, so I’m going to roll up my goodbye and my thoughts on the matter into one, since one is the reason for the other.

    The hatchlings have a voice that heavily suggests they are prepubescent or physically immature compared to the adult form, alongside the underdeveloped wings, neck, tail, and large head which suggests a lack of physical maturity for one. Another is that there is nothing in the lore that supports reasoning for them to drink that young.

    One of your developers cited a map showing a minimum age for alcohol use across the world. While I appreciate what they were trying to say, it felt like it was taken out of context and therefore missing crucial information regarding the execution of those drinking laws.

    I looked into the places that did have younger drinking ages, mostly the 18-19 range since those are the most common and likely who would look at your game if you manage to find a way to advertise to a larger audience. 18-19 counts as being an adult in the majority of those places, the keyword being adult in that they are mature enough mind and body to handle the responsibility of alcohol, they likely are out of high school, pay taxes, able to live without a parent or guardian, and capable of holding down a 40 hour work week if they wish to. In a number of places cited on the map, while beer is fine for 18, they must be 21 for spirits. I also looked at the countries that allowed drinking at 16-17, while I cannot speak for some places, I know from reading the source of the map that had been provided that in most developed places that allow this the minor must be in the presence of a parent or guardian while drinking- this means they are not adults and are not responsible or mature enough to have alcohol on their own. Let us also consider that many of these are also on premise purchase age, meaning they are from a location that does have a liquor license - this could count for your game’s taverns given the need for permits for certain vendors on player property.

    Let us also not forget that in most cases when it concerns minors and alcohol with a parent letting them drink, usually the parent is not letting them slug down an entire bottle of fireball or vodka. As well, any spiritual or religious ceremonies requiring alcohol usually only ask for one sip from a ceremonial vessel, not to drain the entire bottle of holy wine in one go.

    From an outside perspective, it looks like a coding mistake- especially after I had looked into the archives of this forum to try and research into this and found that alcohol and taverns were added by request from the playerbase after launch which suggests that maybe there had been no alcohol in game at launch because it may have looked suspect to have a character that looks and sounds a lot a young child being able to purchase booze and drink. While it is fine to experiment and explore, companies usually want to appeal to as many as possible for the sake of sales if they’re intentionally trying to bring their game to an international level, from what I can tell from you developer’s plans to move the engine to unreal or unity, along with steam support, I assume this is also your intent.

    Maybe in 2004 this was fine since there were no adult dragons implemented yet, as I know that hatchlings were initially the only form of dragons in game, but after 15 years I would have thought if you all wanted to keep that in maybe there would have been something added in-game (not the headcanon vomit I saw in the discord, actual canon) to have it make sense. I would also address how the hatchlings being allowed to gamble in the aftermath of EA’s stint with loot boxes in child games would likely go if you managed to get the game on steam, but that is besides the point and I figure the outcome of that would be obvious if a larger audience took notice given current events and would derail what I am saying.

    For an example of this done right, I have one game to offer. There is one game that managed to pull this kind of mechanic off without feeling like complete skeeve. Dwarf Fortress, an independent title, and the reasoning for alcohol being a staple of diet from birth to death being that it was part of dwarven culture and it is important to their overall happiness and productivity though they can survive on water cited here: http://dwarffortresswiki.org/index.php/Thirst

    The dwarves are also classified as an alcohol dependent race according to lore.

    I know some have also said people don’t like politics in their games, and while that is true, by having a playable child character able to drink alcohol, you kind of walked into it anyway.

    Games, so long as they take things from life and that game interacts with other cultures, will start making statements that seem political whether you intend them to or not. The Dragons and Sslik not having genders, for instance, can be seen as political regarding transgender rights and gender identity, there are other recent games that have the option to choose a gender other than male or female and they sparked plenty of online debates. I could also get into how Blizzard has two versions of WoW in order to appeal to both US market and to the Chinese market in removing visible bones and gore from their undead models on the chinese version of the game as those things are considered a taboo in their culture.

    While it may pain some of you to hear, often respecting the mores of other cultures does win you a lot of perks including maybe, just maybe, additional income.

    Some may also wish to bring up that technically it is wrong for child characters to go gallivanting off on adventures on their own and wonder why I’m not creeped out by that. To that I wish to cite the canon of Pokemon, ten year olds can run around on adventures and have literal pit fights between powerful creatures - but they also are not draining every bottle of sake they find. There are also other types of media that feature minors fighting evil and facing some real disturbing things which can be readily found in mainstream media; the Goosebumps TV show, Mystery Shack, and Steven Universe to a degree - child alcoholism however cannot be readily found outside educational PSA videos and probably for good reason. It is an issue people would prefer to stamp out than promote.

    So long and you all have fun with whatever you’ve got going here, I’m going find something else to put my money towards.
    Last edited by Beaky; February 27th, 2020 at 09:46 PM.

  2. #2

    Default Re: Ight, Imma Head Out

    Sad to see you go, but not sad to see your reasoning go I'd say, Istaria is not the place for real world politics, it never has been, and it very well conforms to its rating. Hope you find a game that fits you more.

  3. #3
    Staff :: Developer Sarsilas's Avatar
    Join Date
    Aug 2016
    Location
    Beyond the Great Barrier
    Posts
    232

    Default Re: Ight, Imma Head Out

    Hi there Beaky. I'm sorry to see you are leaving, and I apologise for any miscommunications I may have created by linking the drinking age map.

    By linking the map, I was simply showing that there are different cultural approaches to the consumption of alcohol. In some cultures it can be consumed at a younger age than in others. In some African countries, there is no legal limit, for instance, such as Angola. I was giving an example in the modern world, but I truly should have referred to medieval times and prior where alcohol limits were far more lax because, in some cases, alcohol was safer than drinking water. As Istaria is set in a medieval style setting, this would have been more appropriate.

    Regardless, we as a company do not endorse children consuming alcohol. It is up to society and adults to prevent this from occurring. Within our game, alcohol is presented as more of a joke item that gives you buffs and effects that may be of use to players. Your character's age itself is a role-play concern, not a gameplay one, so we do not lock things away from your character. Some players remain hatchlings for role-play reasons, but still wish to use the items for their gameplay purposes.

    My avatar was drawn by the generous Scaleeth.

  4. #4
    Member
    Join Date
    Jul 2014
    Location
    Right behind you when you're not looking!
    Posts
    145

    Default Re: Ight, Imma Head Out

    Got to say, I applaud you for writing this. Not that I agree with anything you've written though.

    Hatchlings being only "children", "young", "underage" and so on is something that couldn't be further from the truth. If you'd read into some of the lore at least you'd know that the reason dragons have the Rite of Passage and Ancient Rite of Passage is because when Elial's Riftrender collided into the Sleeper it created a paradox which the world couldn't accept, thus removing both from the plane of the world while also leaving an everlasting effect of the event. As a result the dragon race as a whole stopped growing physically beyond a certain point. (Pretty short version to sum it up)

    Every hatchling you see could thus be older than some Ancients as long as they haven't done the Rite of Passage yet. You're simply forcing your own view of "hatchlings are children" on yourself & trying to do so on others.

    As for the attempt at getting the gambling to go by calling out EA and loot boxes, well, I suggest you read up again how you acquire loot boxes and why EA's practice is frowned upon and even banned in some countries. I'll give a hint though: Gambling. Real. World. Money. with an emphasis on the words 'Real World'.

    Furthermore you're trying to force human views & culture onto another race. Or rather your culture & ways of growing up. Funny seeing as it's all fine for those dwarves there, who are more human-like than the dragons you claim are "children".

    Also, this is a game, a fantasy game. It's supposed to be fun. Don't go trying to pull the real world & its problems into this. Or trying to take the fun out of a game by imposing restrictions on those playing for your own satisfaction.

    I'll gladly be there to welcome you back though should you be willing to drop your real world politics and whatnot at the door to Istaria. But until then, well, hope you find that fun elsewhere.
    Last edited by flamefeniks; February 28th, 2020 at 02:24 AM.
    Light covers night, night fades, when it does, storms come. ~Storm Dragons
    Currently Getting Coppers, gaining Silver, making Gold, Pursuing Mithril!

  5. #5
    Member velveeta's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jul 2006
    Location
    le palais du fromage and industrial complex, cliffside, shepherd's mountain, blight
    Posts
    4,934

    Default Re: Ight, Imma Head Out

    i'm with you, flame. mourningwood is old enough now to drink in 'real life', in some countries. i don't even understand the original post, tbh.
    but everyone has to find fun where they like, and if something here isn't to your liking, then it ain't fun. i have enjoyed beaky's screenies and will miss them, and i wish beaky well in future!
    you can't cast a play in hell and expect angels as actors
    check out my game blog: https://velveeta3.livejournal.com/
    ogle the menagerie:http://www.freewebs.com/velveeta/

  6. #6

    Default Re: Ight, Imma Head Out

    Take care Beaky, never bumped into you but hope you find what you're looking for. Sad to see a new player leave.

    See how easy that is? Why kick a dead horse with your opinions? And following it up with a dissertation to justifying it.

  7. #7

    Default Re: Ight, Imma Head Out

    Ahh, sorry to see ya go, I had sold you some comps and you thought I was too low in price. You were making some great progress in-game. take care of yourself.

Thread Information

Users Browsing this Thread

There are currently 1 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 1 guests)

Similar Threads

  1. New dragon head?
    By Scaleth Drakescale in forum Suggestions
    Replies: 25
    Last Post: June 21st, 2010, 07:45 AM
  2. Poking my head in
    By Icefire in forum Hello
    Replies: 4
    Last Post: January 16th, 2006, 08:13 AM
  3. Head Bangers
    By Velat in forum General Off Topic Posts
    Replies: 0
    Last Post: November 5th, 2005, 10:46 PM
  4. *scratches head*
    By imported_asteral in forum General
    Replies: 13
    Last Post: November 4th, 2005, 03:15 PM

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •