Well you just proved how useless not only your info is, but how useless your opinion is.
Also, statistically speaking, those games have over 100x the amount of players Isty has at any given moment of any day.
So if those games aren't worth a crap, one must think what your opinion is of Istaria? Not a fast thinker, are you?
Isty has promise, I can always admit that. It can shine with a few changes here and there. You, however, don't have promise. You don't even have an open mind.
TL;DR your opinion managed to be wrong (which is quite the feat), and the OP has a very very valid point.